Bay State Showdown Brews Over Historical Horse Racing Machines at Suffolk Downs and Raynham Park

Carlo Griffin · Nov 5, 2026

Bay State Showdown Brews Over Historical Horse Racing Machines at Suffolk Downs and Raynham Park

Massachusetts casino representatives reviewing economic impact studies on proposed racing machines

Wynn Resorts, MGM, and Penn Entertainment have joined forces to oppose a proposal that would install historical horse racing machines at former tracks including Suffolk Downs and Raynham Park, where the devices operate under pari-mutuel betting regulations yet deliver slot-style gameplay. The three operators commissioned separate economic analyses that project annual state tax revenue shortfalls between $45 million and $73 million if the machines proceed, along with hundreds of casino-related job reductions stemming from market overlap. Developer Richard Fields has countered with forecasts of $120 million in fresh tax collections and 1,200 new positions by the third year of operation, framing the plan as a net positive for Massachusetts communities.

Mechanics of the Machines and Track Locations

Historical horse racing terminals replay past races through random number generators that determine outcomes while complying with track-betting statutes rather than casino gaming licenses. Suffolk Downs in Boston and Raynham Park in Taunton stand as the primary sites under discussion, both shuttered for live racing yet retaining infrastructure that could house the equipment without new construction. Observers note that this regulatory pathway allows the machines to bypass the expanded gaming act that governs existing casino resorts, creating the core point of contention between established operators and the new proposal.

Operators Detail Projected Revenue and Employment Effects

Studies funded by the casino companies examined player diversion patterns across the state and concluded that HHR terminals would draw significant volume away from slots and table games already operating under full casino licenses. Data from those reports estimate direct tax losses in the $45 million to $73 million range each year, driven by reduced gross gaming revenue at Wynn, MGM, and Penn properties. Employment figures cited in the same documents point to several hundred positions at risk, primarily in food service, security, and gaming floor roles that depend on steady visitor traffic. The analyses further break down regional impacts, showing that nearby communities could experience secondary effects through diminished local spending by casino employees and suppliers.

Developer Projects Stand-Alone Economic Gains

Richard Fields, the lead proponent behind the historical racing initiative, released independent projections that anticipate $120 million in additional annual tax revenue once the machines reach full capacity. His modeling factors in new visitation from demographics that currently avoid casino floors and highlights 1,200 direct jobs created at the converted tracks by year three, including roles in machine maintenance, customer service, and facility operations. Supporters of the plan emphasize that these positions would concentrate in areas previously tied to racing employment, offering a bridge for workers displaced when live events ended at Suffolk Downs and Raynham Park.

Legislative hearing room where Massachusetts economic development bill negotiations continue

Legislative Negotiations and Timeline Pressures

The dispute has surfaced during ongoing talks over a broader economic development bill that lawmakers hope to advance before the current session concludes. Because the measure remains unresolved, the historical racing question now appears headed for a lame-duck session, where procedural rules allow limited debate but require swift consensus to avoid carrying issues into the next calendar year. Lawmakers have scheduled additional committee reviews in the coming weeks, with both sides preparing supplemental data submissions that compare projected tax flows against the September 2026 Gross Gaming Revenue report issued by the Massachusetts Gaming Commission. That document provides baseline figures for existing casino performance and serves as a reference point for estimating any future cannibalization effects.

Stakeholder Positions and Supporting Evidence

Each casino operator submitted its own set of findings to the legislature, drawing on internal traffic data and third-party econometric models that track cross-market substitution rates. Penn Entertainment focused on southeastern Massachusetts effects, while Wynn and MGM emphasized statewide revenue leakage patterns. In contrast, Fields presented feasibility studies that isolate new market segments and calculate incremental tax contributions without assuming direct competition. Legislative staff have requested side-by-side comparisons of the methodologies to identify overlapping assumptions about player behavior and tax recapture rates.

Conclusion

The Massachusetts legislature now faces a narrow window to reconcile competing revenue forecasts before the lame-duck period ends. Both sets of projections remain on the table as negotiators weigh amendments to the economic development bill, with final decisions likely determining whether historical horse racing machines appear at Suffolk Downs and Raynham Park or remain excluded from the state's gaming landscape.